How do we speed up adoption of new surgical techniques?

Failure to adopt new surgical techniques quickly into everyday clinical practice means NHS patients are missing out on ground-breaking new procedures, warns a new report from the Royal College of Surgeons.

The report, entitled From innovation to adoption: Successfully spreading surgical innovation, sets out for the first time the factors that have helped and hindered the adoption of new surgical techniques in England.

It highlights that from the first antiseptic operation, through to organ transplantation, keyhole techniques and robotic technology, innovation has revolutionised NHS care. From innovation to adoption warns that if we are to continue to be at the forefront of improving patient care, supporting research, new techniques and ideas must become business as usual for the NHS.

Based on an examination of five mainstream surgical procedures the study explores why, after new surgical techniques have been trialled, it can still take years for patients to benefit from them.

Insufficient evidence to prove the safety and effectiveness of a new procedure; ensuring surgeons have the new skills required; investment in new equipment or the need to redesign services (infrastructure) and the level of clinical and patient demand are among the reasons why the widespread adoption of a new surgical procedures is often delayed.

One case study in the report, for Laparoscopic colorectal surgery, starkly outlines the problems.

The quality of the evidence for laparoscopic colorectal surgery meant that the technique received a positive recommendation through NICE’s technology appraisal process, which carries with it a legal requirement for hospitals to make the treatment available within three months.

However, this requirement was waived for four years due to a lack of appropriately trained surgeons in the NHS to deliver the desired workload, meaning the availability of the treatment on the NHS was not mandated.

Strong clinical leadership and advocacy from Sir Mike Richards, then National Clinical Director for Cancer, was instrumental in securing action and adequate funding from the Department of Health to ensure that this legal duty could be fulfilled by training surgical teams which led to the procedure eventually being adopted.

The report seeks to address how to progress the uptake of surgical innovations in a practical way, eradicating delay to ensure their benefits are realised by patients as quickly as possible.

It argues the absence of evidence that a new innovation is truly beneficial can make it harder to secure the funding needed to develop surgical skills and establish the correct infrastructure to support an innovation’s wider use.

The study states that ultimately clinicians must want to use a new procedure and patients must want to receive it, if a treatment is to be widely adopted. This will require the provision of appropriate information on its benefits and risks.

From innovation to adoption also makes six achievable and affordable recommendations, which, if implemented, will benefit patients in future years. Among the recommendations is a call to NHS England to work in partnership with NICE and the Royal College of Surgeons of England to develop a horizon scanning process to quickly identify and review new surgical procedures that have the potential to improve patient care.  Other recommendations include:

– Providers of NHS services should be financially incentivised to support surgical innovation

– NHS England should work in partnership with NICE and the Royal College of Surgeons of England to agree on an appropriate service delivery model. The Royal College of Surgeons should provide advice on training requirements, including the number of centres, to safely introduce the new technique

– Patients should be offered a choice of different surgical interventions that are appropriate for them, including new practices and techniques

– Patient groups should work with surgical specialty associations to develop appropriate information for patients on new surgical procedures

Professor Norman Williams, President of the Royal College of Surgeons, said: “Many patients are not benefitting from groundbreaking procedures even when surgeons firmly believe that they can save or extend lives and improve their quality. This cannot continue.

“We cannot afford to neglect the kind of surgical innovation that has made such a difference to a chance of survival and recovery, for example, in keyhole surgery, advancements in transplant surgery and the rapid developments we are now seeing in robotic surgery. Now is the time for the NHS, the government and the surgical profession to understand how the adoption and diffusion of new, innovative surgical practices can be accelerated.”

Bookmark and Share

Post a Comment

Enter this security code

Submit Comment for Moderation