Posts Tagged ‘Pay’

Balls angers unions by accepting public pay freeze

The Guardian - 14th January 2012 5:45 pm

Ed Balls, the shadow chancellor, says Labour faces “a big task” to regain economic credibility and win back public trust.

In a speech to the Fabian Society on Saturday, Balls said he accepted every spending cut being imposed by the coalition and endorsed George Osborne’s public sector pay freeze, adding that it might need to continue beyond the end of the current parliament.

His announcement, first revealed in an interview with the Guardian, is an attempt to challenge accusations that Labour is not credible on the economy.

Read more in The Guardian.

Chancellor sets out low pay future for NHS staff

By Mike Broad - 29th November 2011 3:09 pm

Chancellor George Osborne says public sector pay rises are to be capped at 1% for two years.

The announcement, delivered during his Autumn Statement, means that NHS doctors will not have had anything like an inflation matching pay rise in six years.

Consultants are currently in the second year of a three year pay freeze, and when that ends will only receive a maximum of 1% salary uplift, if at all, for the ensuing two years.

Pensions are also under review and consultants are likely to have to work longer and make higher contributions for weaker benefits. And there’s still no indication whether this year’s Clinical Excellence Awards programme will be run, as the profession awaits the government’s response to the pay body’s review.

Stephen Campion, chief executive of the HCSA, said: “This announcement reinforces the need for a negotiated settlement on both pay and pensions, although I very much fear that attitudes will harden in the coming weeks. The timing of all this is particularly insensitive coming as it does not only during the pension negotiations but also when the government has been made aware only this week of the need for improved hospital consultant cover at night and weekends.

“Today’s announcement will do little to help the health secretary and NHS Employerswork work with health professionals who will feel even more undervalued than they did before the Chancellor’s announcement.”

Inflation is currently running at around 5%.

The BMA has said it will ballot members on the government’s pension proposals, and is not ruling out an industrial action vote in the future.

Dr Hamish Meldrum, BMA chairman of council, said: “The Chancellor’s decision to bypass the normal pay review process for a further two years and announce another sub-inflationary pay award will come as a bitter blow to all those who work in the NHS.

“Doctors, like their public sector colleagues, are angry at the government’s proposals to slash the value of their pensions. This announcement, coming on top of what will be three years of pay freeze for senior doctors, will further alienate those who are working hard to deliver improvements to patient care.”

Osborne also confirmed that UK economic growth would be lower, and borrowing higher, than was forecast during the Budget in March.

Delivering his Autumn Statement, Osborne told MPs the UK economy was now forecast to grow by 0.9% this year - compared with 1.7% forecast in March and 0.7% next year down from the 2.5% March forecast. This would be followed by 2.1% in 2013, 2.7% in 2014, and 3% in 2015.

The Office for Budget Responsibility has increased its estimate of the public sector jobs expected to go. Previously, the figure was put at around 400,000 - it’s now 710,000.

Daily Mail on the trail of 770K a year GP in Kent

Daily Mail - 18th November 2011 4:47 pm

The top-earning GP in the country receives an annual salary of more than £750,000.

The astonishing pay packet is his or her pre-tax income even after all outgoings - including the salaries of all locums, nurses and receptionists they employ - have been taken into account.

The unidentified GP from Kent is believed to be reaping the benefits of a new contract that allows doctors to run several surgeries that rake in NHS cash for providing extra treatment.

This can include minor operations, tests for diabetes or help for drug addicts.

The extraordinary salary, revealed through a Freedom of Information request, marks the rise of the ‘Super GP’.

Read more in the Daily Mail.

“Pay freeze undermines consultant contract”

By Mike Broad - 16th November 2011 10:20 am

The consultant contract will have been eroded by 16% by the time the two-year pay freeze ends in 2013, the BMA says.

In its submission to the pay review body, the BMA claims doctors are experiencing sizable real-terms pay cuts.

The submission says that doctors have made a significant contribution to constraining NHS costs and this must be recognised when the pay freeze ends.

Last week the government reaffirmed its commitment to a two-year pay freeze for NHS staff, which makes it three years for consultants.

The Department of Health said that staff satisfaction and recruitment and retention “remain healthy” and the total reward package in the NHS is favourable.

On pensions, the government said: “The government has made it clear that future public sector pensions will remain among the best available…any changes in pensions, including the proposed increase in contributions from 2012/13, do not justify upward pressure on pay.”

The BMA submission, however, pointed to the uncertain future of Clinical Excellence Awards; decreased pay banding for juniors; and, fewer programmed activities for hospital doctors.

It called on the pay review body, which is supposedly independent, to comment on the real impact of the pay freeze on the profession.

Consumer Price Index inflation is currently running at 5%.

The government submission concluded: “NHS pay must also been seen within the wider context of the current economic situation and cannot be immune from the serious economic challenges we face.”

The NHS pay freeze was announced in 2010 to support the government’s QIPP targets of saving £20 billion by 2014-15. NHS staff pay will be frozen in 2011/2012 and 2012/2013.

Read more on doctors’ pay scales.

Treasury confirms two-year NHS staff pay freeze

By Mike Broad - 7th November 2011 3:52 pm

The government has submitted evidence to the Doctors and Dentists Pay Review Body supporting its decision to freeze the pay of NHS staff for two years.

The pay freeze was announced in 2010 to support the government’s QIPP targets of saving £20 billion by 2014-15  in order to be able to meet rising demand.

In its evidence the government says: “Delivering these savings will be extremely challenging and any unnecessary increase in pay would make this more difficult, could undermine this ambition and may put at risk our ability to meet growing public expectations.”

NHS staff pay will be frozen in 2011/2012 and 2012/2013. Consultants were already experiencing a pay freeze in 2010/2011, so their pay will not rise over a three-year period.

Pensions are also under review and consultants are likely to have to work longer and make higher contributions for weaker benefits. A day of action by NHS staff is planned for 30 November. And there’s still no indication whether this year’s Clinical Excellence Awards programme will be run, as the profession awaits the government’s response to the pay body’s review.

In its submission on the pay freeze, the government suggests that staff satisfaction and recruitment and retention “remain healthy” and the total reward package in the NHS is favourable.

On pensions, the government said: “The government has made it clear that future public sector pensions will remain among the best available…any changes in pensions, including the proposed increase in contributions from 2012/13, do not justify upward pressure on pay.”

It concludes: “NHS pay must also been seen within the wider context of the current economic situation and cannot be immune from the serious economic challenges we face.”

Public sector staff earning a full-time equivalent salary of £21,000 or less will receive a £250 per year or more increase in salary during this period.

Read the full evidence.

See doctors’ pay scales.

Hospital doctors’ pay scales for 2011/2012

By Mike Broad - 15th September 2011 4:12 pm

In summer 2010, the new Chancellor announced a two-year public sector pay freeze from 2011/12.

Consultants were already experiencing a pay freeze in 2010/2011, so their pay will not rise over a three-year period.

The corresponding freeze in the value of clinical excellence awards will also continue. CEAs will be subject to change, and are likely to be reduced, following a review by the Pay Review Body which will report to the government in summer 2011.

NHS staff earning less than £21,000 will receive a flat pay rise worth £250 in both of the next two years. The Chancellor said the measures would save £3.3 billion a year by 2014-15.

While foundation year doctors, house officers, senior house officers, specialty registrars, specialty doctors, associate specialists and salaried GPs in England received a 1% pay rise for 2010/2011, they are now subject to the pay freeze.

Doctors are also awaiting the government’s response to a review of their pension benefits, with the likelihood of their contributions being increased for inferior benefits.

In 2009/2010, all doctors received a 1.5% pay rise.

Consultant salaries 2011/2012

Threshold 1, years completed as a consultant 0, £74,504, period before eligibility for next threshold one year

Threshold 2, years completed as a consultant 1, £76,837, period before eligibility for next threshold one year

Threshold 3, years completed as a consultant 2, £79,170, period before eligibility for next threshold one year

Threshold 4, years completed as a consultant 3, £81,502, period before eligibility for next threshold one year

Threshold 5, years completed as a consultant 4, £83,829, period before eligibility for next threshold five years

Threshold 6, years completed as a consultant 9, £89,370, period before eligibility for next threshold five years

Threshold 7, years completed as a consultant 14, £94,911, period before eligibility for next threshold five years

Threshold 8, years completed as a consultant 19, £100,446

Clinical excellence awards for consultants

Level 1 £2,957

Level 2 £5,914

Level 3 £8,871

Level 4 £11,828

Level 5 £14,785

Level 6 £17,742

Level 7 £23,656

Level 8 £29,570

Bronze/Level 9 £35,484

Silver/Level 10 £46,644

Gold/Level 11 £58,305

Platinum/Level 12 £75,796

More on Clinical Excellence Awards

Trainee salaries 2011/2012

Grade FHO1

Point minimum, no band £23,533, 1C band (20%) £26,895, 1B band (40%) £31,377

Point 1, no band £25,002, 1C band (20%) £28,574, 1B band (40%) £33,336

Point 2, no band £26,470, 1C band (20%) £30,251, 1B band (40%) £35,293

Grade FHO2

Point minimum, no band £27,798, 1C band (20%) £33,358, 1B band (40%) £38,918

Point 1, no band £29,616, 1C band (20%) £35,540, 1B band (40%) £41,463

Point 2, no band £31,434, 1C band (20%) £37,721, 1B band (40%) £44,008

Grade StR

Point minimum, no band £29,705, 1C band (20%) £35,646, 1B band (40%) £41,587

Point 1, no band £31,523, 1C band (20%) £37,828, 1B band (40%) £41,133

Point 2, no band £34,061, 1C band (20%) £40,874, 1B band (40%) £47,686

Point 3, no band £35,596, 1C band (20%) £42,716, 1B band (40%) £49,835

Point 4, no band £37,448, 1C band (20%) £44,938, 1B band (40%) £52,428

Point 5, no band £39,300, 1C band (20%) £47,160, 1B band (40%) £55,020

Point 6, no band £41,152, 1C band (20%) £49,383 1B band (40%) £57,613

Point 7, no band £43,003, 1C band (20%) £51,604, 1B band (40%) £60,205

Point 8, no band £44,856, 1C band (20%) £53,828, 1B band (40%) £62,799

Point 9, no band £46,708, 1C band (20%) £56,050, 1B band (40%) £65,392

Specialty doctor salaries 2011/2012

Scale value minimum, £36,807, period before eligibility for next pay point one year

Scale value 1, £39,955, period before eligibility for next pay point one year

Scale value 2, £44,046, period before eligibility for next pay point one year

Scale value 3, £46,239, period before eligibility for next pay point one year

Scale value 4, £49,398, period before eligibility for next pay point one year

Scale value 5, £52,546, period before eligibility for next pay point two years

Scale value 6, £55,764, period before eligibility for next pay point two years

Scale value 7, £58,983, period before eligibility for next pay point two years

Scale value 8, £62,201, period before eligibility for next pay point three years

Scale value 9, £65,419, period before eligibility for next pay point three years

Scale value 10, £68,638

Associate specialist salaries 2011/2012

Scale value minimum, £51,606, period before eligibility for next pay point one year

Scale value 1, £55,754, period before eligibility for next pay point one year

Scale value 2, £59,901, period before eligibility for next pay point one year

Scale value 3, £65,378, period before eligibility for next pay point one year

Scale value 4, £70,126, period before eligibility for next pay point one year

Scale value 5, £72,095, period before eligibility for next pay point two years

Scale value 6, £74,665, period before eligibility for next pay point two years

Scale value 7, £77,235, period before eligibility for next pay point two years

Scale value 8, £79,805, period before eligibility for next pay point three years

Scale value 9, £82,375, period before eligibility for next pay point three years

Scale value 10, £84,948

Read the full pay scales.

Consultant contract pay wiped out by inflation

By Mike Broad - 13th June 2011 10:02 am

Improvements in pay under the 2003 consultant contract have been wiped out by subsequent sub-inflation pay rises, the deputy chair of the BMA’s consultants committee has warned.

Figures from the NHS Information Centre show that doctors have been receiving below inflation pay rises since 2007, with the Consumer Price Index exceeding 2% for much of that period. Doctors’ salaries would be up to £10,000 higher had they risen with inflation over that three year period, says an article in the BMJ.

Consultants on the new contract had a mean basic salary per full time equivalent of £85,475 in 2007-8, which increased to £90,133 in the last quarter of 2010. Had their basic salary in 2007 increased each year with inflation according to CPI, they would be on £92,582 at the end of 2010, £2448 more than they actually received that year.

Consultants on the old contract had a mean basic salary per full time equivalent of £83,100 in 2007-8, which had increased to £86,300 by the end of 2010. If their basic salary in 2007 had increased each year with inflation, they would be earning £90,009 at the end of 2010, a difference of £3709.

Seniors are currently subject to a three-year pay freeze to 2013.

Commenting on the stats, Dr Paul Flynn, deputy chair of the BMA’s consultants committee, said: “Consultant pay has been falling behind inflation so that any improvement in consultant pay as a result of the new contract in 2003 has effectively been cancelled out.”

He added: “Consultants are looking at what they’re earning becoming less and less valuable as time goes on, and that leads to a sense of not being valued, and once people start feeling that they’re not being valued for the work that they do it can be very hard to keep up morale and keep going through what is a difficult job.”

Junior doctors have also had below inflation pay rises since 2007. In 2007-8, junior doctors got a pay award of 1.5%, whereas CPI inflation that year was 2.3%. Similarly, in 2009-10 junior doctors still got pay award of only 1.5%, whereas CPI inflation was 2.2%, an effective pay cut of 0.7%.

Foundation doctors and STs would be almost £1500 richer, equivalent to three months’ rent in many parts of the UK, if their mean basic salary per full time equivalent had increased each year with CPI.

As a group, junior doctors’ mean basic salary increased from £29,250 to £30,167 between 2007-8 and 2010, whereas it would have increased to £31,682 had it kept track with CPI inflation over this period.

“These figures hammer home the exact detriment junior doctors are facing financially, exacerbated by the steady increase in student debt that newly qualified graduates inherit,” said Dr Shree Datta, co-chair of the BMA’s junior doctors committee.

“At a time when the NHS faces one of the biggest upheavals in its history, valuing and engaging staff has never been more critical. Given that pay over the rest of the public sector, and in the private sector, has increased by approximately 2% over this period, it is difficult to justify the significantly lower increases for the most junior doctors. One potential outcome could be an adverse impact on recruitment and retention of doctors.”

In April 2011, CPI inflation hit 4.5%.

Read more on hospital doctor pay scales.

National CEA awards likely to be suspended

By Mike Broad - 24th May 2011 10:38 am

The Department of Health has asked the advisory body on doctors’ pay, which is currently reviewing the Clinical Excellence Awards system, to consider closing the scheme in England for new awards.

The move has come to light because ACCEA, the independent body which manages the CEA scheme, has contacted medical societies warning them that there may be no 2012 round if the pay body (the DDRB) heeds the government’s prompt.

A letter from ACCEA medical director Dr David Lindsell and chairman Professor Jonathan Montgomery says: ‘The Department of Health has recently submitted a further paper to the DDRB asking them to consider whether the 2012 round should include applications for new awards. The alternative is that the 2012 round is run for renewal applications only. The DDRB have been asked to make a recommendation on this when they report.’

The DDRB - which has a history of listening to the government - is expected to submit its report to the DoH in July, with its recommendations on the way forward for the CEA scheme in England.

Stephen Campion, chief executive of the HCSA, commented: “Until the DDRB reports to government in July 2011 it would be quite premature for trusts to depart from the Clinical Excellence Award Scheme which is currently available to all eligible consultants.

“By making the 2012 scheme available only for renewal applications the very independence of the DDRB is undermined. If this request from the Department is accepted within the NHS it would send the signal that amendments to the scheme are not driven by the DDRB but overly influenced by the Department of Health.”

In its submission to the review, the Department of Health proposed a ‘slimmer’ system of national awards with trusts being given control of local awards from 2012.

The DoH said then: ‘Trusts will be able to choose whether to have a local scheme, the criteria for making awards and how much to spend on their scheme. This approach responds to the wishes of employers to have greater freedoms to design processes that reflect local priorities and considerations.’

This followed a submission by NHS Employers to the DDRB saying that awards should not be pensionable, protection should end and any available money - as a result of the reform - should be redistributed directly to employers, to use as part of their pay and reward system.

The ACCEA letter to registered medical societies suggests that following the review submission in July there will be ‘a further period during which the Department will consider its response to the recommendation’.

It continues: ‘We are aware that some of you will be thinking about starting your processes for the 2012 round, with some of you possibly having already done so. We wanted to make sure you were aware of the request by the Department.’

Dr Mark Porter, chairman of the BMA’s consultants committee, said: “This reminds me of the pause in the [Health] Bill, where the NHS just carries on restructuring regardless. Here, the Department of Health has referred CEAs for review, and has now told everyone not to await the review but just get on with cutting consultant pay.

“It’s as if they no longer value the professional effort and excellence that consultants bring to the NHS. We will make strong representations on behalf of our members.”

Consultant pay has been frozen over a three-year period, and a review of the NHS pension is likely to result in an increase in contributions for doctors with a reduction in benefits.

Read more on the government’s view of CEAs.

Read more on CEA levels.

Pay jumps by 4.5% for trust chief executives

By Mike Broad - 11th May 2011 1:10 pm

The basic pay of NHS chief executives rose by an average 4.5% last year, research reveals.

The NHS Boardroom Pay report, by Incomes Data Services, shows the median total earnings for CEOs reached £158,800.

The increase is three times higher than the Department of Health’s pay guidance ‘recommendation’ of 1.5%. It follows an average pay rise of 6.9% in the previous year.

Steve Tatton, editor of IDS Compensation Review, said: “The government has stressed the importance of senior staff in the public sector showing leadership in the exercise of pay restraint in the current economic climate.

“With salary rises running at these levels such restraint so far does not seem to have been a feature of boardroom pay deliberation, especially in foundation trusts.”

The median total earnings of CEOs in foundation trusts was £164,500 compared to £152,500 for non-foundation trust CEOs. Foundation trusts have more independence over remunerating their executives in comparison with other health organisations.

Tatton added: “The government wants to bear down on senior executive pay in the public sector, yet it also wants to see decisions made locally without interference from central authorities. The issue for NHS organisations is will they be free to pay their senior executives what they decide is necessary or will they have to follow externally imposed pay restraints.”

The research also suggests that the turnover of boardroom managers is increasing.

NHS consultants will not receive a pay rise between 2010 and 2013. In 2009-2010, they received a 1.5% pay rise.

Read the report.

List of top earners in NHS management

By Mike Broad - 3rd May 2011 1:52 pm

An investigation by The Sunday Telegraph reveals at least 660 NHS managers earn more than the Prime Minister. Here’s a listing of the top 25:

1. David Bennett £282,500

Was interim chief executive of Monitor, independent regulator of NHS foundation trusts, from March 2010 to February 2011

2. Neil Lloyd £282,500

Chief executive, NHS Professionals

3. Ruth Carnall £277,500

Chief executive, London Strategic Health Authority

4. Sir Ron Kerr £274,500

Chief executive, Guy’s and St Thomas’s NHS Foundation Trust

5. Sir Robert Naylor £262,500

Chief executive, University College London Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust

6. Peter Morris £262,000

Chief executive, Barts and The London Trust

7. Clare Chapman £252,500

Director general of workforce, Department of Health

8. Sir Andrew Cash £243,100

Chief executive, Sheffield Teaching Hospitals Foundation Trust

9. Dr Mark Goldman £242,500

Chief executive, Heart of England Foundation Trust until July 2010

10. David Dalton £232,600

Chief executive, Salford Royal NHS Foundation Trust

11. Sir Neil Mckay £232,500

Chief executive, East of England

12 Sir Leonard Fenwick £232,500

Chief executive, The Newcastle upon Tyne Hospitals Trust

13. Dame Barbara Hakin, £227,500

Chief executive, East Midlands strategic health authority

14. Tim Smart £227,500

Chief executive, Kings College Hospital Foundation Trust

15. Ken Bremner £225,000

Chief executive, City Hospitals Sunderland Foundation Trust

16 Alan Foster, £223,400

Chief executive, North Tees and Hartlepool foundation Trust

17. Maggie Boyle

Chief executive, The Leeds Teaching Hospitals Trust 222 500

18. Robert Dolan, £220,000

Chief executive, East London Foundation Trust

19. Dr Gareth Goodier £217,500

Chief executive, Cambridge University Hospitals Foundation Trust

20. Prof Ann Sheen £217,500

Chief executive, Royal Berkshire Foundation Trust (until March 2010)

21. Cally Palmer £217,500

Chief executive, Royal Marsden Foundation Trust

22. Sir Ian Carruthers £217,500,

Chief executive, South West Strategic Health Authority

23. Malcolm Stamp £217,500

Chief executive, University Hospitals Coventry and Warwickshire

24. Dr Frank Harsent £213,800

Chief executive, Gloucestershire Hospitals Foundation Trust

25. Mike Deegan £212,500

Chief executive, Central Manchester University Hospitals Foundation Trust

Read the full listing.