Posts Tagged ‘NHS Board’

Time to let Simon Cowell sort out the NHS

By Bob Bury - 28th October 2010 10:57 am

So, only one in four docs think the government’s health reforms will work?

Considering it’s the GPs who are going to be running everything under the new dispensation, I’m surprised it’s as many as that. I’ve yet to find a GP who thinks they will be up to the job, so it’s no wonder that proper doctors (i.e. hospital ones) are equally sceptical.

Mind you, it’s our own fault. For ages, we’ve been wittering on about the need to involve us in the running of the health service. Unfortunately, our masters seem to have misunderstood our use of that word ‘involve’. We didn’t mean we wanted to actually do anything. We wanted the sort of involvement that requires us to attend a committee meeting once a month, thereby getting us out of an outpatient clinic, or operating session, and home in time to surprise the wife with the milkman; the sort that gives us something to put on the CV and gets us up the Clinical Excellence Award ladder with the minimum of effort.

What we didn’t want was a bunch of speccy GPs in cardigans running the NHS for the benefit of the sad assortment of freeloading benefit scroungers and tired-all-the-time inadequates who fill their waiting rooms.

We need bosses who understand the needs of proper patients - those with life-threatening bleeding, big nasty lumps or interesting syndromes. And we need bosses who recognise the need of the consultant body for a proper work/life balance, and a steady supply of properly-trained juniors to take care of the work half of that equation. It’s all a bit depressing, really.

Personally, I think we should give Simon Cowell a crack at it. After all, he does know how to get the best out of a bunch of untalented prima donnas while still turning a healthy profit. The X-factor panel could simply be re-badged as the ‘NHS Board’ that I seem to remember David Cameron promising us - you know, the organisation that was going to run the NHS at arm’s length from government once he got his hands on the levers of power.

So what happened Dave? Well, now’s your chance to deliver. Admittedly, it’s hard to know what useful function Louis Walsh would serve on the Board - so no change there, then. On the other hand, I can think of a number of ways to employ Dannii and Cheryl, but probably best not to go there.

Now I come to think about it, the X-factor solution would also address a number of other NHS agendas, not least transparency and patient choice. Televise the Board meetings, and when there’s a decision to be made on resource allocation (e.g. dialysis for children in renal failure or mobility scooters for obese, work-shy patients with ‘fibromyalgia’) the couch potatoes can phone in. There - job done. Shame about those anuric kids, though.

Weighing up the pros and cons of aping the BBC

By Bob Bury - 9th February 2010 9:57 pm

It has often been said that the NHS would benefit from being run by an independent corporation, rather like the BBC, at arm’s length from government. Well, the Tories say that’s exactly what they’ll do, a fact that I’ve referred to elsewhere, having previously been in favour of it myself.

OK, the BBC might not be the most inspiring example, given that it’s currently under fire from every quarter, not least from those same Tories, but the principle should be a good one, given that we spend most of our time complaining about the political micromanagement of healthcare.

And yet, and yet. The more I think about it, the less sure I am that it’s a good idea - it will all depend what sort of outfit this ‘NHS Board’ turns out to be, and the trouble is, I suspect we all know the answer to that question, don’t we? We’d like it to be composed of respected medical professionals (not necessarily medical politicians - in fact, specifically not medical politicians) plus the cream of the sensible NHS managers (yes, there are some - you know there are).

However, we’ll probably get saddled with a bunch of professional quango members - those benighted souls who move from one highly-paid  sinecure to another, having never experienced a proper job in their lives; a couple of politicans with a health connection (Frank Dobson, bless him, will be a shoo-in); a clutch of businessmen with good Tory cost-cutting (sorry, modernising) credentials and, if we’re lucky, a couple of doctors prepared to take the DoH shilling in return for a gong. And, oh yes, almost forgot, a few over-promoted nursing Dames who haven’t been near the dirty end of a patient in 20 years, but who have acquired certificates and diplomas in facilitation, process engineering and service improvement.

The worst case scenario would be if the Board is brought into existence simply to oversee the piecemeal selling-off of the NHS to the private bidder offering the cheapest deal. This is a process already well advanced under Nulabour, and anyone who thinks the Tories won’t continue, or even accelerate, the privatisation of health care learned nothing from the Ken Clarke years (and it is truly remarkable that those of us who were around then find ourselves looking forward to the return of a Conservative government - a testimony, if one were needed, to the sheer awfulness of Labour rule).

Just as I was putting the finishing touches to that last paragraph, David Cameron announced that one of his first acts on taking power will be to abolish the post of chairman of the BBC, so I think we all know who’ll be our new boss.

Cynical, moi?