Posts Tagged ‘Baby P’

Great Ormond Street doctors want Baby P inquiry

BBC Health - 1st July 2011 9:47 am

Doctors have demanded a government investigation into why London’s Great Ormond Street Hospital kept information from the original Baby Peter inquiry.

They have backed a similar call from Home Office minister and Lib Dem MP Lynne Featherstone, who wants the hospital’s chief executive to quit. The hospital failed to share findings of a highly critical report into St Ann’s Clinic in Haringey.

Abused toddler Peter Connolly was treated there two days before he died.

During a serious case review into Peter Connelly’s death in August 2007, Great Ormond Street commissioned an independent investigation by two of the country’s most experienced paediatricians, Professor Jo Sibert and Dr Deborah Hodes.

But it produced an edited version of their report and passed that - not the original - to the review.

Now a number of unidentified consultants have written to the medical journal The Lancet calling for “strong ministerial intervention” to establish what happened.

Read more at BBC Health.

Baby P whistleblower offered apology by GOSH

The Guardian - 16th June 2011 5:21 pm

Great Ormond Street Hospital has formally apologised to a senior doctor suspended after she blew the whistle on failings at the clinic where Baby Peter was treated just days before his death.

Consultant paediatrician Kim Holt and three colleagues wrote to managers in 2006, warning that understaffing and poor record keeping posed a serious risk to patients’ safety at St Anne’s clinic in Haringey, north London.

Holt says bosses ignored her warnings and removed her from the clinic.

Peter Connelly was seen by an inexperienced locum doctor Sabah Al-Zayyat at St Anne’s in the summer of 2007, three days before he was killed and after Holt and her fellow whistleblowers had left.

Holt says the hospital offered her £120,000 to withdraw her complaints in the wake of Peter’s death - a claim the hospital denied.

The apology, which was issued jointly by the hospital and Haringey PCT, says: “Both Trusts accept and are sorry that you have been through a difficult time. You are a respected and valued member of staff and we look forward to you resuming your role in community paediatrics very soon”.

Holt, who has been on paid leave for much of the past three years, is now understood to have returned to work with a new NHS employer, Whittington hospital, also in north London.

Read more in The Guardian.

Shoesmith wins appeal over Baby P sacking

BBC Health - 27th May 2011 2:39 pm

Ex-children’s services director Sharon Shoesmith says she is “thrilled” to have won a Court of Appeal battle over her sacking after Baby Peter’s death.

Judges said then education secretary Ed Balls and her employers, Haringey Council, had been “procedurally unfair” when they sacked her three years ago. The education department and Haringey plan to appeal to the Supreme Court.

Baby Peter Connelly, who had been seen 60 times by social services, was found dead in 2007 with over 50 injuries.

Shoesmith’s appeal was challenging a High Court ruling that cleared Ed Balls, the north London borough of Haringey and watchdog Ofsted, of acting unlawfully. The Court of Appeal judges dismissed her appeal against Ofsted.

Balls said he “strongly disagreed” with the judgement and added that his decision had been based on a report from independent inspectors.

Read more at BBC Health.

Baby P doctor ‘voluntarily erased’ from the register

BBC Health - 11th February 2011 8:53 pm

A doctor who said she failed to spot that the abused toddler Peter Connelly, known as Baby P, had a broken back has been removed from the medical register.

Consultant paediatrician Dr Sabah Al-Zayyat was facing action at the GMC over t0 the care of the 17-month-old, who died in 2007.

But a GMC panel granted her request for “voluntary erasure” from the register, meaning she avoids a full hearing.

It also means that she can still practise outside the UK.

Peter died in Haringey, north London, after suffering months of abuse. A post-mortem examination found he had suffered multiple injuries. He had received 60 visits from authorities.

Read more on BBC Health.

Baby P doctor wins right to challenge GMC hearing

BBC Health - 31st October 2010 10:35 pm

A doctor accused of failing to spot signs that Baby P was being abused has won the right to legally challenge a GMC disciplinary hearing against her.

Dr Sabah Al-Zayyat is seeking to overturn a GMC ruling that refused to grant her “voluntary erasure” from the medical register on health grounds.

The judge ordered that her challenge be heard in the High Court in November.

The GMC panel must stop its hearing until the challenge is heard, he said.

Dr Al-Zayyat’s counsel argued that the panel’s decision was “perverse” in the light of medical evidence that the doctor is not well enough to participate in the hearing

Read more at BBC Health.

Baby P doc’s voluntary removal from register refused

BBC Health - 25th October 2010 5:42 pm

A doctor accused of failing to spot signs that Baby P was being abused has had her application to be removed from the medical register rejected.

Dr Sabah Al-Zayyat, who is facing disciplinary action over her conduct, had applied for “voluntary erasure” from the medical register.

This would have avoided the need for a full misconduct hearing.

The GMC has ruled that the “serious” allegations against her should be heard in public.

The GMC could ban her from UK working. Chairman Ralph Bergmann said: “The panel considers that to accede to the application for voluntary erasure would avoid a public, and necessary, examination of the facts of this case.”

Read more at BBC Health.

Baby P doctor wants to quit practising medicine in UK

BBC Health - 12th October 2010 10:14 pm

A doctor accused of failing to spot signs that Baby P was being abused is seeking to quit practising medicine in the UK.

Dr Sabah Al-Zayyat was originally due to face misconduct allegations in February, but the hearing was adjourned after the panel heard she was suicidal.

The GMC has now heard that the locum paediatrician is renewing a bid to apply for ‘voluntary erasure’ from the medical register. It could ban her from working in the UK.

Dr Al-Zayyat’s lawyer Mary O’Rourke said the application for voluntary removal from the medical register would be based on “medical grounds” because the doctor is “unfit to stand trial and defend herself”.

Read more at BBC Health.

Baby P whistleblower to sue Great Ormond Street

BBC Health - 20th September 2010 11:40 am

A doctor who raised concerns about the clinic where Baby P was seen days before his death is suing the NHS, claiming she was forced out of her job.

Consultant paediatrician Dr Kim Holt is seeking £100,000 from her employer Great Ormond Street Hospital.

After making the complaint she claims her workload increased as consultant posts were cut and she was signed off with stress in February 2007

She now works in a different area of the trust and, she claims, has not been allowed back to her original post.

Solicitors Leigh Day & Co said Dr Holt had filed a personal injury claim against the central London children’s hospital.

Read more at BBC Health.

Looking forward to not having to pay the hangman

By Bob Bury - 19th July 2010 6:24 pm

A couple of weeks ago I was reporting my incredulity at the fact that the GMC had apparently got something right. Twice. But now normal service has been resumed, and just when I thought that nothing they could do could make me more dissatisfied with them than I already am, along comes their judgement in the case of Dr Jerome Ikwueke, the GP involved in the Baby P case.

They found that there were ‘serious failings‘ in his handling of the case, but then, he wasn’t alone in that. However, the fitness to practise panel chairman Dr Judith Worthington, said: “You don’t pose a risk of repeating this behaviour and there’s no evidence of deep-seated attitudinal or personality problems.” She also admitted that the GP had taken the appropriate remedial measures personally, and had changed procedures at his practice to minimise the risk of any similar failing in the future. She said, and who could disagree with her, that striking him off the register would not be “proportionate or in the public interest”. So what did they do? They suspended him (i.e. struck him off) for a year.

Which will achieve exactly what? It will deprive his patients of a GP they clearly have a lot of respect for (the panel received numerous testimonials to the quality of his care for them), and he will have a year away from his profession, with no income and no opportunity to put into practice the retraining he has already undertaken. I think we all know why the GMC took this craven action, but unusually, they actually came out and admitted it for once. They suspended the GP, said Dr Worthington, “in order to maintain public confidence in the profession and to declare and uphold proper standards of conduct and behaviour”.

In other words, they did it to appease the Daily Mail readers, whose spittle-flecked twin sets and florid, broken-veined complexions bear testimony to their incoherent and all-consuming need for a culprit. Any culprit. The GMC clearly accept that nothing beneficial will be achieved by Dr Ikwueke’s suspension, but it would rather pander to the general public’s lust for vengeance than make a reasoned case for allowing him to continue practising.

I have to laugh when people say it’s time that the medical profession lost the right to self-regulation. If this is self-regulation, I’d far rather take my chances with a lay judicial body, funded from public money, in the event that I was accused of malpractice. At least then I wouldn’t, in effect, be paying the hangman myself. The GMC should stick to their job of maintaining the register, and I reckon 20 quid a year should be plenty for that.

Baby P GP suspended for a year by GMC

BBC Health - 16th July 2010 4:08 pm

A GP who saw Baby Peter eight days before his death has been suspended from working as a doctor for 12 months.

The General Medical Council had already ruled there were “serious failings” in Dr Jerome Ikwueke’s care.

Peter, from north London, died aged 17 months in August 2007 after sustained abuse.

Dr Ikwueke, 63, who was the family’s GP, had noted that the toddler was not his “usual happy self”, seemed “withdrawn” and pulled away when he saw him for the last time on July 26 2007.

The GMC had said the GP breached his professional duty towards the child in not carrying out a full examination, making an urgent referral for further checks or sharing information with a health visitor or social workers.

Read more at BBC Health.