Hospital Dr News

Female doctors pass exams and secure jobs

Female doctors are more likely to pass their exams or be offered a training post than men, GMC data reveals.

Reporting for the first time on exam results and job applications, the data shows that ethnic minority doctors from UK medical schools do less well than their white counterparts. But, they do better than white doctors from a non-UK medical school.

The report is based on two new sets of data: recruitment data showing doctors applying for specialty and general practice (GP) training programmes after completing foundation training (F2). This covers the first round of national recruitment in each year from 2012 to 2014 into specialty and GP training.

And, examinations data from a single academic year from the Medical Royal Colleges showing pass rates for doctors in specialty and GP training. This covers more than 100 different exams.

Broad trends in training post applications after the foundation programme suggest that across specialties, medical schools and postgraduate training, women are more likely to be offered a place on a training programme.

Doctors with an undergraduate medical degree from outside the UK were less likely to be offered a specialty or GP training place than those who attended a UK medical school.

BME doctors are less likely to be offered a place on a training programme than white applicants.

Trends in examinations data showing pass rates for doctors in specialty and GP training suggests doctors who were in a UK training programme when taking the exam were more likely to pass than those who were not. And women are more likely to pass than men.

BME doctors from a UK medical school were less likely to pass than white doctors from a UK medical school. Pass rates were 63.5% and 76% respectively.

BME doctors from a UK medical school were more likely to pass than white doctors from a non-UK medical school.

The GMC has acknowledged that the current data is limited – it covers only one year of exam outcomes and three years of round one recruitment data.

Niall Dickson, Chief Executive of the GMC, said: “We have to treat this new information with care – the exam data is only based on one year’s figures and we do not yet understand why these differences occur. But being open about all this is a vital first step to analysing what is going on and doing something about it.

“We know too that postgraduate exam pass rates vary between graduates of different medical schools and between postgraduate training programmes.

“The data may help identify examples of good practice, where effective support has been given to doctors in training who have found it more difficult to pass exams or progress into specialty or GP training.

“We must never compromise standards but if we are going to achieve a high quality and fair system of training doctors for the future, we need to understand more about how doctors are progressing through their training now.”

The report is part of a wider programme of work which the GMC is undertaking with the Royal Colleges and those who fund postgraduate education to investigate barriers that affect how doctors progress through training.

Dr J-P van Besouw, Vice –Chair and Education Lead for the Academy of Medical Royal Colleges, said: “It is clear that while the issue of differential attainment is not simply about exams or indeed confined to the medical profession, we must strive for fairness and equality of opportunity in terms of gender, ethnicity and country of origin in the examination process.

“Quality and patient safety do, however, have to be the first consideration in any medical examination process. Beyond that, they must always be fair and free from any discrimination and bias and that there should be no factors within the control of Colleges that contribute to differential attainment.

“This analysis shows us that while we have made a good start in seeing where any potential discrepancies may exist, there is further work to be done and much more data will be required if we are to have any insight into the possible causes of those discrepancies if we are to understand how they can be eradicated.”

Read more.

Bookmark and Share

One Response to “Female doctors pass exams and secure jobs”

  1. Yvette P says:

    It is interesting how these findings appear to corroborate those found in my paper looking at factors that increase and decrease likelihood of passing ARCP as well: http://bmjopen.bmj.com/content/5/2/e005658.full

Post a Comment

Enter this security code

Submit Comment for Moderation