Messy Business

Weird and wonderful stories from the theatres, wards and corridors of our hospitals. To contribute email editorial@hospitaldr.co.uk

Yo dude, it’s not about the money, money, money

By Mike Broad - 1st February 2012 2:32 pm

Ah, the age old battle between medics and surgeons for bragging rights isn’t just a UK thing.

Our orthopods might have stronger grips than anaesthetists (see previous post), but the ‘internists’ come out on top in this amusing American ‘commercial’.

Orthopods - strong, clever and not at all insecure

By Mike Broad - 21st January 2012 9:58 pm

BMJ’s Xmas ‘funny’ is worth a mention (albeit a month late).

An orthopod or two were clearly enraged by THIS a couple of years ago. The rest of us - 70,000 and rising - watched it and sniggered.

The slighted orthopods didn’t just sit around smarting however. They bided their time and pulled together a ground-breaking piece of research that - for once and for all - puts anaesthetists back in their ‘box’.

Orthopods are stronger and cleverer - ip dip phooey, you gas monkeys and no returns!!! (I look forward to the return).

A lesson in how to bring a profession’s power to bear

By Mike Broad - 7th January 2012 8:35 pm

Not exactly a ‘funny’ this week, more a point of interest.

I see that trainee doctors in Israel have won bonuses, higher pay, a commitment to only six late night and weekend shifts a month, and a contract review in 2015.

What did it take? Demonstrations, walk outs and mass resignations over a 160-day period. Israeli Medical Association chief Dr Leonid Eidelman even staged a 10-day hunger strike to pressure the government.

So are doctors in the UK going to be able to resist the NHS pension proposals, for example, with a disgruntled moan to their local BMA rep and a letter to their local MP.

Err, no.

However, even with the successful campaign of mass professional action in Israel there has been a price to pay. From now on, hospital doctors are going to have to clock in and out to show they are doing the hours they say.

Now don’t go giving the Department of Health any ideas…

Don’t make decisions after five pints (even if they’re water)

By Mike Broad - 8th December 2011 6:50 pm

In all this ‘run-up-to-Christmas excitement’ (that seemed to start sometime in October) I clean forgot to update my dear readers on this year’s Ig Nobel Prizes.

As anyone who reads this column knows, I’m a bit of a fan. They’re the prizes that celebrate unusual academic endeavour and are handed out to researchers that have first made people laugh, and then make them think.

This year’s medicine prize was a good one. Two teams of researchers on different sides of the globe independently proved that people make better decisions about some kinds of things - but worse decisions about others when they have a strong urge to urinate.

Now I know why I bought a Christmas tree that doesn’t fit in my house, a potter’s wheel for my wife (as a romantic gesture), and board games (remember them) for the children… Note to self: no lattes before going Xmas shopping.

Here’s the references for the nerds among you…”Inhibitory Spillover: Increased Urination Urgency Facilitates Impulse Control in Unrelated Domains,” Mirjam A. Tuk, Debra Trampe and Luk Warlop, Psychological Science, vol. 22, no. 5, May 2011, pp. 627-633.

“The Effect of Acute Increase in Urge to Void on Cognitive Function in Healthy Adults,” Matthew S. Lewis, Peter J. Snyder, Robert H. Pietrzak, David Darby, Robert A. Feldman, Paul T. Maruff, Neurology and Urodynamics, vol. 30, no. 1, January 2011, pp. 183-7.

Arrhythmia is a dancer, it’s a source of companion…

By Mike Broad - 7th November 2011 11:23 pm

My favourite bit of Touching the Void, a scary but ultimately uplifting mountaineering film, is when our hero reflects on his impending death.

Joe Simpson has fallen down a mountainside, breaking various bits of his body, before crawling for several days through crevasse fields without food or water.

He’s about to die, and half expects a moment of profound insight before he passes. Instead all he gets is Boney M’s Brown Girl in the Ring playing over and over again in his mind. He doesn’t even like Boney M.

CPR is the reason I mention this. Bear with me, there is a link of sorts.

As far as I’m aware, Stayin’ Alive by the Bee Gees is the internal song of choice when compressing the chest of a heart attack victim, which is more than a little ironic. If you do use this tune, ask yourself this important question: is it always internalised? Or, in the heat of the moment, do you start murmuring it?

Other CPR tunes include Nelly the Elephant, Disco Science (no, I hadn’t heard of it either but then I don’t get out much) - which is apparently the best - and a well known number by Billy Ray Cyrus.

Please God, don’t let me die listening to a whispered version of Achy Breaky Heart.

Anyway, the research suggests it’s all a waste of time so no more disco tunes - you know who you are.

However, no one is going to stop me dancing arrhythmias. It doesn’t help my clinical practise - after all I’m not a doctor - but I just like it, OK! (And here’s a more modern version.)

So are you allowed to play music in theatre or not?!

By Mike Broad - 29th September 2011 2:34 pm

Hmmm, methinks someone has something to push (like a DVD of House).

‘Research’ suggests that 90% of surgeons listen to music while they operate, and half of those said up-tempo rock was their genre of choice.

Seventeen per cent favour pop music, while 11% said they listened to classical music while they operated. Patients undergoing plastic surgery were most likely to be operated on by a music-loving doctor, with all plastic surgeons surveyed said they listened to music while operating.

Maybe the private practice boys and girls play a bit more fast and loose with ‘the rules’ than the Nash. Last time I checked most trusts had banned music in theatre over new copyright laws.

Please update me somebody, otherwise I’ll be stuck in this Land of Confusion (Genesis). Sorry.

Equal opportunities? Why would you need that in anaesthetics…

By Mike Broad - 14th September 2011 7:02 pm

It just doesn’t pay to be too honest in the good old Nash.

So many times we write things that simply pay lip service to a regulation or bureaucrat. But occasionally we don’t and all hell breaks loose.

As someone in HR at the Royal Liverpool Hospital is about to find out.

At the bottom of a published advert for a trainee anaesthetist was the following statement about adding “the usual rubbish about equal opportunities”.

Oops. Someone should have proofed that copy. Cue inquiry.

A trust spokeswoman confirmed that an investigation has been launched. She said: “The wording on this advert in no way reflects the Royal Liverpool and Broadgreen University Hospitals NHS Trust’s position in relation to equal opportunities, to which it is fully committed.”

Thank God that’s been cleared up. I can sleep easy now.

Health lessons all the way from Gaston County Jail

By Mike Broad - 18th August 2011 2:35 pm

Is the Health and Social Care Bill a once in a life time opportunity to put doctors in charge of the NHS, or the beginning of the privatisation of our national treasure?

I’m not going to pretend to have the answer. But certainly there are plenty of people at the BMA and NHSCA who believe it’s the latter.

If we are indeed taking a significant step towards a more US-styled system, there was a pertinent message in the plight of James Verone.

Unemployed American Verone got fed up with being unable to afford treatment for a slipped disc, arthritis and a growth on his chest.

His solution - rob a bank. But far from demanding a vast sum from the cashier he only asked for one dollar. Then instead of hot footing it away he just sat down in the corner and awaited the police.

He’d already sent a letter to the local paper, the Gaston Gazette, saying: “When you receive this a bank robbery will have been committed by me for one dollar. I am of sound mind but not so much sound body.”

Verone was sent to Gaston County Jail and was happy to arrive. Why? Because he achieved his aim - free healthcare courtesy of the prison system.

Moving from paediatric cardiology to boogie-woogie

By Mike Broad - 28th July 2011 2:33 pm

The consequences of saving someone’s life are profound, though sometimes a little obscure.

Dr Michael Rigby is a consultant paediatric cardiologist at the Royal Brompton Hospital and in the course of his work successfully treated the daughter of musician Elio Pace, when she was just a few days old.

It saved her life and Elio was determined to recognise Dr Rigby’s contribution in some way. After much persistence, Dr Rigby agreed to a ‘thank you’ in the shape of piano lessons.

He had trained to grade 5 in classical piano but wanted to learn boogie-woogie. It turned out to be Elio’s forte, and now Dr Rigby is rather good at it. So good, in fact, that they did their first gig recently to raise funds for the hospital.

“Considering he is such a talented musician, when it comes to teaching, he has a wonderful ability to keep things simple and make it fun. I never forget his tips and advice,” Dr Rigby says.

The good doctor might even support Elio on his forthcoming nationwide tour in September.

Now that’s how to hit a heart warming ‘thank you’ note….(sorry).

Davis: “A monster with lipstick on is still a monster”

By Mike Broad - 7th July 2011 3:12 pm

Jacky Davis, consultant radiologist, co-chair of the NHSCA, BMA council member and Hospital Dr blogger, definitely won ‘the best turn of phrase award’ at the BMA’s annual representatives meeting.

She’s been one of the loudest voices in the campaign against the coalition government’s NHS reforms, but she really pulled out all the speech writing stops last week when she said the Bill would still lead to the privatisation of the NHS.

“We are being sold a respray job, two write offs welded together, and we need to look under the paintwork to see what’s there.”

She swiftly moved from car analogies to more melodramatic ones, reminding the audience that the Bill was originally christened ‘Lansley’s monster’ by the BMJ.

“The politicians took it away, slapped on some lipstick and asked us to embrace it,” she said. “But a monster with lipstick is still a monster. It needs to be terminated with extreme prejudice.”

It must have worked - delegates voted for the BMA leadership to push for more change. But surely the Royal Society for the Protection of Political Monsters should be made aware of her ruthless intentions…