Archive for August, 2010

GP referrals on the rise again, DoH figures show

Pulse - 31st August 2010 12:33 pm

GP referrals to secondary care appear to be accelerating again, with the latest figures from the Department of Health showing a 6% year-on-year rise in the first quarter of 2010/11.

DH figures on outpatient referrals and attendances show the number of GP referrals made from April to June this year increased by 169,000 to 3 million.

The number of other referrals made has also increased, by 136,000 to 1.7 million - an 8.7% increase against the first quarter of 2009/10.

The figures show that, after an apparently successful clampdown by primary care organisations determined to curb the rise in referrals, GP referrals are beginning to creep up again.

Last month primary care tsar Dr David Colin-Thome said that GP contracts would be re-written to ‘reward them for how much they can benefit from being more efficient providers of care in, say, making less inappropriate use of hospital services.

Read more at Pulse.

Playing ‘pooh sticks’ will never be the same again

By Bob Bury - 9:10 am

Being of a ‘certain age’, I have just received my faecal occult blood testing kit as part of the colorectal cancer screening programme. I must say, it’s all very well put together, with little spatulas and a set of intructions so simple and clear that a gynaecologist could follow them. It does feel odd, though, to find yourself examining your own motions for the first time in 62 years. It all seems a bit, I don’t know…French. And the next time my little granddaughter asks if we can play ‘pooh sticks’, I’ll get a mental image of those spatulas.

Actually, I’m almost hoping that the test produces a (false) positive result, so that I need a colonoscopy. I had to have one a few years ago (false alarm - diverticular disease), and I really enjoyed it. No, don’t get me wrong. It wasn’t the ‘oscopy itself, it was the drugs - pethidine and medazolam…mmmmmmm. Although I was at medical school in London during the swinging sixties, the free love/drugs thing passed me by completely, and the only drug-induced highs I have ever experienced have involved being pissed, and even then, I just tend to get maudlin and start showing people pictures of my kids. The old i/v sedation though, that was something else. I didn’t notice the procedure itself, and if the gastroenterologist had seen something interesting down the scope and had decided to crawl in himself to get a better look, I don’t think I’d have noticed that either. My wife, who drove me home, tells me the stupid grin (mine, that is) lasted for several hours. I can quite understand how that sort of thing could get addictive, he said, stating the bleeding obvious.

Still, it’s good to have a national screening programme that involves men as well as women, I’d begun to think we didn’t count. Is there a ribbon for colon cancer, and if so, what colour is it? Still mustn’t get on to the subject of ribbons just now - that’s a whole rant in itself, and could be a useful filler for one of these blogs if I find myself without a topic.

And this inconsequential contribution has taken so long to complete, that the result of my screening test has, improbably, been posted back to me in less than a week. And it’s negative, which means I’ll have to look elsewhere for mood-altering substances. And of course, now I’m thinking to myself ‘it’s only a screening test though - with a 75% sensitivity, you could still have cancer’. Lucky old patients - they are happy when they get the ‘all clear’. Too much knowledge, and all that.

Burnham urges Lib Dems to oppose Tory reforms

The Guardian - 30th August 2010 8:28 pm

Andy Burnham, the shadow health secretary and Labour leadership contender, reached out to Liberal Democrats to call for a public debate over the coalition’s NHS reforms.

“Changes are being forced on the NHS with no consultation, no piloting and no evidence,” he wrote in a letter to Lib Dem MPs. “I do not believe that the people who voted for you at the election voted for such a radical break-up plan.”

He warns of a postcode lottery in the NHS where private patients can leapfrog the queue because the Tory health secretary, Andrew Lansley, has dumped Labour’s waiting time targets.

Burnham’s office said it wanted Lib Dems to look again to what was happening to the NHS - and the pitfalls of a policy that was being challenged in the courts.

Read more at The Guardian.

NHS sees ninefold increase in bariatric surgery

The Guardian - 9:29 am

The NHS has seen a ninefold rise in five years in the number of surgical procedures performed on obese patients to try to reduce their weight.

The figures illustrate the challenge the government faces in trying to tackle the problem of obesity. In 2008-09, the NHS carried out 4,246 weight loss operations, including stomach stapling and fitting gastric bands, compared with 480 procedures in 2003-04, according to the NHS Information Centre.

Of the operations performed in 2008-09, 42 involved full or partial removal of the stomach; 1,378 involved fitting a gastric band to make the stomach smaller; 504 involved stomach stapling; 2,210 involved a gastric bypass; and 124 inserting a “bubble” in the stomach to fill it up. Patients may have undergone more than one procedure in the same operation. The upward trend in the data suggests the figures for 2010 could be higher.

Read more at The Guardian.

Putting the blame game in perspective

By Katherine Teale - 29th August 2010 12:55 pm

I was walking down the corridor today when I almost bumped into one of my colleagues. When I say “bumped into” I mean he nearly knocked me down the stairs in his effort to pretend I don’t exist.

The three people with me were greeted with cheerful ‘hellos’, but I have evidently committed a crime for which I must be soundly ignored. I’ve no idea what this offence is - perhaps he holds me, as clinical director, personally responsible for the hospital’s economic doldrums.

Whatever it is he’s kept this up for six months now without accidentally letting slip even a hint of a smile when we pass one another in theatre, so you have to admire his reflexes and persistence. It must be quite an effort to be so consistent about this - I doubt whether I could remember whom I’m not saying ‘hello’ to quite so successfully. Perhaps he keeps a list written on the back of his hand.

Talking about blame, there’s been lots of it around this week. The internet is full of the shocking story of the two year old who had a plaster of Paris cast applied to the wrong arm. This wasn’t noticed by anyone until the following day when mum was so traumatised that she had to go straight to the press.

This report is followed by the inevitable seven pages of public vitriol, the gist of which is that doctors and nurses are an overpaid, underworked bunch of idiots who can’t even tell right from left and should be sacked. Or worse. The fact that the nurse involved had tried to calm the distressed toddler by putting a cast on her teddy bear first only seemed to fan the flames of public outrage, as apparently they had managed to treat the correct arm on the teddy, but sadly not on the child.

Anyone who has tried to treat a distressed, screaming two-year-old will understand that it wouldn’t be immediately obvious which was the arm with the greenstick fracture. Presumably all the angry citizens expressing disbelief that the NHS can be so crap have A. never made a mistake, and B. never heard of ‘human error’.

I suppose it’s just more fun to post, while frothing at the mouth, about how some incompetent junior doctor, who might even have been foreign, took three attempts to put a drip up when you were in casualty. Of course, what the hospital in question needs to do, after publishing a grovelling apology, is institute a checklist system in A&E whenever a procedure like that is performed, even when the patient is awake.

We’re already doing this in theatres using the WHO check list which has been mandated by the National Patient Safety Agency. It’s entirely about avoiding human error - children can’t tell you when you’re doing the wrong thing, and even wide awake adult patients will allow nerve blocks, for instance, to be performed on the wrong side, without a word of protest.

Despite what we might think from the internet message boards, most patients assume we know what we’re doing. Whether they’re always justified in doing so is another question.

Regulation of drug abuse is better than prohibition

By Dr James Bell, addictions consultant at the South London and Maudsley NHS Trust - 11:26 am

Sir Ian Gilmore’s comments on “decriminalising” drug use while still regulating drug sales are welcome. I read the former president of the Royal College of Physician’s words this week between seeing patients in a south London drug dependence clinic.

The first patient was a young woman, barely coherent under the influence of prescribed benzodiazepines (anti-anxiety medication and sleeping tablets).

Next was an affable chap who has been on prescribed diamorphine for more than a quarter of a century, while running a successful business and leading an upright suburban life.

As pointed out in the 1970s by the American research of Norman Zinberg, the effect of drugs is determined by “drug, set and setting” - the action of the drug, the mindset of the person using it, and the social context. When discussing how to regulate drugs, we must clarify the particular problems that drug policy is seeking to address.

Some of the many faces of drug use were shown in the Channel 4 documentary series, Our Drugs War. Residents of a bleak housing estate claimed in the film that 60% of inhabitants were on heroin. Watching, it was hard not to nod wisely and conclude that deprivation, unemployment, and social and family breakdown have been the fertile breeding ground for heroin addiction.

This part of the series also interviewed people about the former “legal high”, GBL, revealing a different face of our drug epidemic. For the most part people using GBL are young, often privileged, employed people who use a range of drugs as part of their party lifestyle.

In university towns, this type of drug use is commonplace if not without risks, including overdose fatalities. I have seen charming, privileged and formerly hardworking young people who found themselves dependent on GBL neglecting friends, family and work commitments and experiencing severe withdrawal symptoms when they try to stop.

And then there is alcohol, with per capita consumption in the UK having risen over the last two decades - and with it, deaths from liver disease.

It is hard to avoid the conclusion that there is a high demand for drugs across the UK. So availability becomes a key determinant of consumption. Historically, alcohol and tobacco have been regulated by licensing and taxation.

Taxation is surprisingly effective; there is consistent data that even addicted people reduce consumption when the price of their chosen drug goes up.

However, successive UK governments have been reluctant to use taxation and licensing to restrict the harm associated with alcohol (and tobacco), justifying the position on the grounds that the use of alcohol is a matter of “personal responsibility” rather than an area for intervention by the nanny state. Yet they have been glaringly inconsistent in dealing with the use of other psychoactive drugs, regarding that not as a matter of personal responsibility but as criminal behaviour.

Prohibiting the use of certain drugs has proved moderately ineffective (GBL can still be ordered online for next-day delivery). Instead, this strengthens the link between crime and drugs, and breeds disrespect for the law.

Most aspects of modern life require a mix of personal responsibility and regulation.

Licensing laws and taxation are not “nannyism” but prudent measures to restrain excess. Similar regulation of other drugs may offer a more constructive approach than the current legal restrictions. Given the plentiful availability of black-market drugs, it is hard to imagine such a policy being worse than our existing regime of classification.

This article first appeared in The Guardian

Developing leadership skills - guidance for new consultants

By Dr Emma Sedgwick, joint director of Healthcare Performance - 10:18 am

The MDU has developed new guidance for doctors embarking on their first consultant post. In the first of a series of articles guiding doctors through the common non-clinical challenges they might face, Dr Emma Sedgwick from Healthcare Performance, looks at some of the skills needed to become a successful leader.

Why develop leadership skills?

The GMC’s Good Medical Practice and Management for Doctors both recognise leadership as a key part of doctors’ professional work, regardless of specialty and setting. There are a number of specific skills associated with leadership which doctors can develop and improve.

Leadership framework

To be an effective leader, it is important to have vision, direction and clear focus on priorities for the organisation or department. There are a number of different leadership frameworks which can help a consultant achieve their potential as an effective leader. One of the best known is the Medical Leadership Competency Framework. This was developed specifically for doctors by the Academy of Medical Royal Colleges and the NHS Institute for Innovation and Improvement.

This framework describes the leadership competencies doctors need in order to become more actively involved in the planning, delivery and transformation of health services. The framework is set around five domains:

Personal qualities - such as developing self awareness and acting with integrity.

Working with others - such as building and maintaining relationships and working within teams.

Managing services - such as planning and managing resources, people and performance.

Improving services - such as ensuring patient safety and encouraging improvement; and

Setting direction - such as making decisions and evaluating impact.

Personal qualities

Just as important as vision, direction and focus, a doctor needs a good understanding of their own approach and style of working. There may be many things a consultant does not have absolute control of in the workplace such as team size, the level of resources and the demand for services. But a consultant can choose how to approach and respond to professional challenges.

Identifying a leadership style

There are numerous theories on the topic of leadership and leadership styles. Different situations demand different leadership styles. There may be times when an authoritative style is appropriate, and others when a more participative style will be better suited to the task at hand.

Developing flexibility in leadership can be the greatest challenge: knowing when to use different skills in the different situations is sometimes described as the mark of an effective leader.

Developing leadership qualities

A consultant may want some help identifying their own leadership style. There are a number of ways this can be approached such as finding out how the framework mentioned above can be applied, developing greater self-understanding by taking one or more psychometric tests - such as the Myers Briggs type indicator, or participating in a formal leadership scheme, or employing a career coach.

Why time management is a good skill to develop

Time is a limited - and therefore precious - resource. Effective leaders need to be able to manage their limited time. Developing techniques for using time more effectively can have beneficial consequences, for example it can help a doctor to achieve a good balance between work and home life.

Time management tools (adapted from Mind Tools)

1. Overcoming procrastination

The greatest enemy to effective time management is procrastination. We’re all familiar with the notion that when you should be doing something you don’t want to start, any lowly task can seem more attractive. Once a doctor acknowledges that they’re procrastinating there are techniques they can apply to overcome these hurdles.

2. Break the task into smaller chunks

To overcome feeling completely overwhelmed, break the task down into smaller tasks. A doctor can then start with the smallest and easiest task. Once that has been achieved - even if it’s a small part of the whole - a person feels better as they’re on the way. So, for example, instead of thinking “I will write the whole of the report this weekend”, list out the component parts which make up the whole task - for example, the background, methodology, findings and conclusions. Each of these areas can be further divided into even smaller, more manageable chunks.

3. Prioritise tasks

If a consultant is looking to concentrate on a particular project they need to look at scheduling their time. They should look at the available time by day, week or over the coming month. Next, they need to list out all the various tasks to achieve the goal and break these down into smaller tasks. Then the doctor should consider which tasks are both the most urgent and the most important. The truly urgent and important tasks should be scheduled in first. The least important and least urgent tasks should be scheduled in at the end, when the doctor has achieved the others. Using this technique a busy person should find it easier to fit in everything you need to do.

They should also try to avoid switching between tasks. It is tempting for consultants to keep checking emails, for example, and therefore getting distracted from what they’re really doing.

Once the tasks have been planned and prioritised, the doctor can ask someone else to hold them accountable. Getting a good friend or relative to ring or email the person to ask if they’ve completed the task yet can help.

Consultants can also cost out their time. They should consider how much their time is worth per hour, then add up how much time, and therefore money they’re effectively wasting by not getting on with the task in hand.

4. Choose a role model

Chances are a more experienced colleague is very organised and good at using their time. They effortlessly manage a number of different things at the same time, do them well and meet deadlines. Ask the person you know how they do it and learn their tips and solutions for time management. These tips should be put into practice and, if necessary, they can be asked for more information and the recipient can further refine their techniques.

5. Timing

We all have a time of day when we are most alert and efficient. A doctor should find out when theirs is. It may be first thing in the morning, or late at night. It doesn’t matter when it is, just exploit the times when you can really focus on work and get far more done.

6. Reward yourself at the end

If you need to tackle an unpleasant job, focus on the outcome and set yourself a reward for when it is completed. Try to imagine what it will be like when you have done it.

Consultants should remember that even small changes to the way they manage their time can have a significant impact.

The MDU’s new consultant pack contains 18 fact sheets on subjects such as communicating with patients and colleagues, good record keeping, supervising staff and marketing and media. Part one of the pack covers leadership skills and is available free to the MDU’s consultant members.

Dr Emma Sedgwick is a joint director of the company Healthcare Performance Ltd which provides coaching, workshops and consultancy to healthcare organisations. Emma, who trained as a child and adolescent psychiatrist, previously worked as a medico-legal adviser at the MDU and now leads the MDU’s communication skills workshops.

Government confirms plan to scrap NHS Direct

BBC Health - 28th August 2010 4:57 pm

The government has confirmed it is planning to scrap the NHS Direct telephone service in England and replace it with a cheaper option.

A new 1-1-1 helpline is already being piloted in north-east England.

It was previously reported that the new service may replace NHS Direct, but now the Department of Health has confirmed it will definitely do so.

The move comes as the government curtails public spending, even though it has promised to protect the NHS.

Around 40% of NHS Direct staff are currently trained nurses, whereas the 1-1-1 helpline centres are expected to employ significantly fewer nurses.

The change will not affect existing NHS helpline services in Scotland and Wales.

Read more at BBC Health.

Bloodgate doctor did not act in “player’s interests”

The Guardian - 9:17 am

The doctor at the centre of the Bloodgate saga did not act in the best interests of the rugby player she cut to cover up a bogus injury, a disciplinary panel said today.

Dr Wendy Chapman previously said she was “ashamed” that she gave into pressure from the Harlequins winger Tom Williams, who wanted to conceal that, minutes earlier, he had bitten into a fake-blood capsule.

His fake injury meant a specialist goal kicker could come on to the pitch in the dying minutes of last April’s Heineken Cup rugby union quarter-final tie against Leinster, who held on to win 6-5.

Dr Chapman had already admitted almost all the charges levelled against her by the General Medical Council, which said her conduct on the matchday, and at a later European Rugby Cup disciplinary hearing, was likely to bring the profession into disrepute and was dishonest.

Read more at The Guardian.

Dr Ubani’s gagging order application rejected

Healthcare Republic - 8:58 am

Dr Stuart Gray, the GP whose father was killed by German locum Dr Daniel Ubani, has welcomed a court decision to reject a gagging order against himself and his family.

The court in Kempton, Germany, rejected the application by Dr Ubani for an injunction, which aimed to impose a ban on Dr Gray and his brother Rory Gray from talking to the press across Europe, including the UK.

The court ruled that the brothers can continue to brand Dr Ubani a “charlatan” and a “killer” but said the sons are not permitted to use “animal”.

Dr Gray said this is a “major milestone” for his family and that he will now concentrate on getting Dr Ubani struck off the medical register across Europe.

Read more at Healthcare Republic.